Hey Leader,
When you run a meeting and nobody disagrees with you, what does that tell you?
Maybe you made a compelling argument and everyone is on board.
Or maybe your team has learned that disagreeing with you isn’t worth the trouble.
I’ve spent enough time in executive meetings to know that the person doing the most talking isn’t always the person with the best idea. And a room full of nodding heads is not necessarily a room full of agreement.
If you’re the leader, you need to know the difference.

Are you hearing the whole story?
This week inside my Be That Girl Collective, I challenged the women to make room for another woman’s voice. Maybe that meant inviting a colleague into the discussion, recognizing a contribution that was overlooked, or making sure someone got to finish her thought.
That matters for a very practical reason: better decisions require information you may not already have.
Picture a meeting about an important client problem. You’ve reviewed the numbers, you’re confident in your recommendation, and you explain how the team should proceed.
Someone raises a concern. Before she finishes, you explain why you’ve already considered it. Nobody else pushes back. Everyone agrees on the next steps, and the meeting ends early.
You may have made the right decision. But you’ve also made it without hearing information that could have changed your thinking.
And when you’re responsible for the outcome, that’s a risk worth paying attention to.
The bigger problem is what happens next.
If people repeatedly learn that challenging your thinking leads to a lecture, they may stop trying. Now you’ve created a situation where people are managing your reactions instead of helping you manage the business.
That can be expensive.

Three questions for your next meeting
1. Who’s doing most of the talking?
If it’s you, ask yourself whether you’re leading the conversation or filling all the available space. You don’t need to prove you’re the smartest person in the room. You need the information required to make the best decision.
2. Whose perspective haven’t you heard?
Don’t assume silence means agreement. If someone has relevant knowledge, invite the perspective directly. Try: “We’ve heard a few views. What are we missing?” Then allow enough time for an answer.
3. What happens when someone challenges you?
Notice your first reaction. Do you ask a follow-up question, or immediately explain why you’re right? You don’t have to agree with every suggestion. But if you want honest information, people need to know it’s worth bringing you the uncomfortable parts, too.
Now, ladies, let’s look at the other side.
Because maybe you’re the person with something valuable to say.
You see a risk nobody is discussing. You have an idea that could improve the result. Or you want to ask for the next opportunity, but you’re worried about how your boss will respond.
So you hold back. Then you replay the meeting on the drive home, thinking about everything you could have said.
I understand why. Timing matters. Relationships matter. Sometimes speaking up has real professional consequences. You need to think about what you want to accomplish and how to approach the person in front of you.
But being strategic is not the same as continually talking yourself out of contributing.
And that’s why advice like “just be more confident” isn’t enough. Confident about what? What do you actually say when your boss dismisses your recommendation in front of the leadership team? How do you ask for a promotion after you’ve been told you’re not ready?
Those situations take judgment, preparation, and practice. They deserve more than a pep talk.
That’s why I’m bringing back the free Be That Girl Live Series.
Starting November 30, I’m hosting three free Zoom conversations for women who want to work through the real situations they’re facing at work. We’ll consider examples from the group, talk about different ways to respond, and choose something practical to try.
This is a separate, free event. You do not need to belong to the paid Be That Girl Collective to participate.
SEE IT | Monday, November 30 at 5:30 PM ET
Recognize the moments and patterns that cause you to hold back.
OWN IT | Wednesday, December 2 at 5:30 PM ET
Understand the situation, the outcome you want, and the options in front of you.
USE IT | Friday, December 4 at 12:00 PM ET
Take what you’re learning into the real world and talk about what happened.
Each session is approximately an hour, live on Zoom, and completely free. If you attended in September, I’d love to have you back with a new situation.
Because you can know what effective leadership looks like and still struggle when a real conversation doesn’t go according to plan. Knowing what to do and doing it when it counts are two different skills.
That’s what we’re going to practice.
Your ally in leadership,
Stephanie
P.S. Gentlemen, the leadership lesson applies to you, too. And if a woman you know would benefit from these conversations, I’d appreciate you passing the invitation along. Your Ally in Leadership is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.


